Are Banks from Mars, Mobile Banking Technology Vendors from Venus?


Although talked about for years, mobile banking has become a reality in 2010, to the point where it is viewed as the “fifth channel” of banking. By the end of this year, the majority of top 50 US banks with retail operations will offer some form of mobile banking, and there will be about 18 million mobile banking active users. Reaching large financial institution saturation, the banking and mobile vendor technology industries are rapidly approaching a point where competition will centre around innovation.

To gain a better understanding of these views, Celent interviewed 11 banks (all but one in the Top 50 category) and 10 mobile banking technology vendors in a new report, Are Banks From Mars, Mobile Banking Technology Vendors From Venus?

Banks and vendors have similar “big picture” views of how innovation will play out. They share a belief in the growth potential of mobile banking, including the acquisition of high-cost, offline customers. Both parties are nearly unanimous in their views that certain front end functionalities, such as real time alerts and P2P (person-to-person) payments will be important in the near future.

There is also a strong consensus that mobile banking has to be a channel of its own, not an appendage of online banking, and greater integration with back end core banking systems is required. Most players in both industries are clearly hoping for mobile-related fee opportunities.

“Both parties feel that mobile channel monetization will eventually occur,” says Red Gillen, senior analyst with Celent’s banking group and author of the report. “However, many of these hopes for monetization appear to be out of line with early adopter, in-market solutions, including free mobile P2P and RDC products.”

There are also many areas where banks’ and vendors’ views understandably diverge. Banks tend to take a broader approach, having to worry about multiple channels, systems, and organizational units. On the other hand, vendors are mainly concerned with a narrower approach, because mobile technology is their niche field of expertise.

Expectations regarding some of the “next big thing” elements of mobile banking also differ. Banks are taking a very cautious approach to mobile-based marketing, whereas vendors see unrivalled potential for the mobile marketing channel. NFC payments and downloadable apps represent other front end functionalities where the two industries do not always see eye to eye.

Key findings of the report include: